NCAA History
| Division III Champions |
| Year |
Champion |
Score
|
Runner-Up |
| 1985 |
TCNJ |
7- 4 |
Ursinus |
| 1986 |
Ursinus |
12-10 |
TCNJ |
| 1987 |
TCNJ |
8- 7 (OT) |
Ursinus |
| 1988 |
TCNJ |
14-11 |
William Smith |
| 1989 |
Ursinus |
8- 6 |
TCNJ |
| 1990 |
Ursinus |
7- 6 |
St. Lawrence |
| 1991 |
TCNJ |
7- 6 |
Ursinus |
| 1992 |
TCNJ |
5- 3 |
William Smith |
| 1993 |
TCNJ |
10- 9 |
William Smith |
| 1994 |
TCNJ |
29-11 |
William Smith |
| 1995 |
TCNJ |
14-13 |
William Smith |
| 1996 |
TCNJ |
15- 8 |
Middlebury |
| 1997 |
Middlebury |
14- 9 |
TCNJ |
| 1998 |
TCNJ |
12-11 (OT) |
Williams |
| 1999 |
Middlebury |
10- 9 |
Amherst |
| 2000 |
TCNJ |
14- 8 |
Williams |
| 2001 |
Middlebury |
11-10 (2OT) |
Amherst |
| 2002 |
Middlebury |
12- 6 |
TCNJ |
| 2003 |
Amherst |
11- 9 |
Middlebury |
| 2004 |
Middlebury |
13-11 (OT) |
TCNJ |
| 2005 |
TCNJ |
9-7 |
Salisbury |
| 2006 |
TCNJ |
10-4 |
Gettysburg |
| 2007 |
Franklin & Marshall |
11-8 |
Salisbury |
| 2008 |
Hamilton |
13-6 |
Franklin & Marshall |
| 2009 |
Franklin & Marshall |
11-10 |
Salisbury |
