Year Champion Coach Score Runner-Up Site 2020 Canceled due to Covid 19 -- -- -- -- 2019 North Central Jeff Thorne 41-14 Wisconsin-Whitewater Shenandoah, Texas 2018 Mary Hardin-Baylor Pete Fredenburg 24-16 Mount Union Shenandoah, Texas 2017 Mount Union Vince Kehres 12-0 Mary Hardin-Baylor Salem, Va. 2016 Mary Hardin-Baylor Pete Fredenburg 10-7 Wisconsin-Oshkosh Salem, Va. 2015 Mount Union Vince Kehres 49-35 St. Thomas (Minn.) Salem, Va. 2014 Wisconsin-Whitewater Lance Leipold 43-34 Mount Union Salem, Va. 2013 Wisconsin-Whitewater Lance Leipold 52-14 Mount Union Salem, Va. 2012 Mount Union Larry Kehres 28-10 St. Thomas (Minn.) Salem, Va. 2011 Wisconsin-Whitewater Lance Leipold 13-10 Mount Union Salem, Va. 2010 Wisconsin-Whitewater Lance Leipold 31-21 Mount Union Salem, Va. 2009 Wisconsin-Whitewater Lance Leipold 38-28 Mount Union Salem, Va. 2008 Mount Union Larry Kehres 31-26 Wisconsin-Whitewater Salem, Va. 2007 Wisconsin-Whitewater Lance Leipold 31-21 Mount Union Salem, Va. 2006 Mount Union Larry Kehres 35-16 Wisconsin-Whitewater Salem, Va. 2005 Mount Union Larry Kehres 35-28 Wisconsin-Whitewater Salem, Va. 2004 Linfield Jay Locey 28-21 Mary Hardin-Baylor Salem, Va. 2003 St. John's (Minn.) John Gagliardi 24-6 Mount Union Salem, Va. 2002 Mount Union Larry Kehres 48-7 Trinity (Texas) Salem, Va. 2001 Mount Union Larry Kehres 30-27 Bridgewater (Va.) Salem, Va. 2000 Mount Union Larry Kehres 10-7 St. John's (Minn.) Salem, Va. 1999 Pacific Lutheran Frosty Westering 42-13 Rowan Salem, Va. 1998 Mount Union Larry Kehres 44-24 Rowan Salem, Va. 1997 Mount Union Larry Kehres 61-12 Lycoming Salem, Va. 1996 Mount Union Larry Kehres 56-24 Rowan Salem, Va. 1995 Wisconsin-La Crosse Roger Harring 36-7 Rowan Salem, Va. 1994 Albion Pete Schmidt 38-15 Washington & Jefferson Salem, Va. 1993 Mount Union Larry Kehres 34-24 Rowan Salem, Va. 1992 Wisconsin-La Crosse Roger Harring 16-12 Washington & Jefferson Bradenton, Fla. 1991 Ithaca Jim Butterfield 34-20 Dayton Bradenton, Fla. 1990 Allegheny Ken O'Keefe 21-14 Lycoming Bradenton, Fla. 1989 Dayton Mike Kelly 17-7 Union (N.Y.) Phenix City, Ala. 1988 Ithaca Jim Butterfield 39-24 Central (Iowa) Phenix City, Ala. 1987 Wagner Walkt Hameline 19-3 Dayton Phenix City, Ala. 1986 Augustana (Ill.) Bob Reade 31-3 Salisbury Phenix City, Ala. 1985 Augustana (Ill.) Bob Reade 20-7 Ithaca Phenix City, Ala. 1984 Augustana (Ill.) Bob Reade 21-12 Central (Iowa) Kings Island, Ohio 1983 Augustana (Ill.) Bob Reade 21-17 Union (N.Y.) Kings Island, Ohio 1982 West Georgia Bobby Pate 14-0 Augustana (N.Y.) Phenix City, Ala. 1981 Widener Bill Manlove 24-10 Dayton Phenix City, Ala. 1980 Dayton Rick Carter 63-0 Ithaca Phenix City, Ala. 1979 Ithaca Jim Buttersfield 14-10 Wittenberg Phenix City, Ala. 1978 Baldwin-Wallace Lee Tressel 24-10 Wittenberg Phenix City, Ala. 1977 Widener Bill Manlove 39-36 Wabash Phenix City, Ala. 1976 St.John's (Minn.) John Gagliardi 31-28 Towson Phenix City, Ala. 1975 Wittenberg Dave Maurer 28-0 Ithaca Phenix City, Ala. 1974 Central (Iowa) Ron Schipper 10-8 Ithaca Phenix City, Ala. 1973 Wittenberg Dave Maurer 41-0 Juniata Phenix City, Ala.