| Year | Champion | Coach | Points | Runner-Up | Points | Host or Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2018 | Denison | Gregg Parini | 596.5 | Emory | 369.5 | Indianapolis, Indiana |
| 2017 | Emory | Jon Howell | 438 | Kenyon | 384 | Shenandoah, Texas |
| 2016 | Denison | Gregg Parini | 455.5 | Kenyon | 418.5 | Greensboro, NC |
| 2015 | Kenyon | Jess Book | 468 | Denison | 383 | Shenandoah, Texas |
| 2014 | Kenyon | Jess Book | 480 | Denison | 472 | Indianapolis |
| 2013 | Kenyon | Jess Book | 499.5 | Denison | 428 | Shenandoah, Texas |
| 2012 | Denison | Gregg Parini | 600 | Kenyon | 519 | Indianapolis |
| 2011 | Denison | Gregg Parini | 500.5 | Kenyon | 499.5 | Knoxvile, Tenn. |
| 2010 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 696 | Denison | 272 | Minneapolis |
| 2009 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 604 | Emory | 402 | Minneapolis |
| 2008 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 635 | Johns Hopkins | 330 | Wooster |
| 2007 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 570 | Denison | 351 | Houston |
| 2006 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 498 | Denison | 345 | Carleton |
| 2005 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 556.5 | Emory | 404.5 | Hope |
| 2004 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 678.5 | Emory | 446 | St. Louis |
| 2003 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 756.5 | Johns Hopkins | 384.5 | Emory |
| 2002 | Kenyon | Peter Casares | 589 | Johns Hopkins | 382 | Miami (Ohio) |
| 2001 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 669 | Emory | 289.5 | Buffalo |
| 2000 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 670.5 | Denison | 317 | Emory |
| 1999 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 670 | Denison | 382.5 | Minneapolis |
| 1998 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 726 | UC San Diego | 395 | St. Louis |
| 1997 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 689.5 | UC San Diego | 336 | Oxford, Ohio |
| 1996 | Kenyon | Jon Howel | 572.5 | Denison | 360 | Emory |
| 1995 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 687 | Hope | 295 | Oxford, Ohio |
| 1994 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 615.5 | UC San Diego | 389.5 | Williams |
| 1993 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 552 | UC San Diego | 442.5 | Emory |
| 1992 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 646 | UC San Diego | 361 | Buffalo |
| 1991 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 593 | Claremont-M-S | 280 | Emory |
| 1990 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 653 | UC San Diego | 535 | Wheaton (Ill.) |
| 1989 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 630 | UC San Diego | 486 | Bowdoin |
| 1988 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 552 | Claremont-M-S | 314 | Emory |
| 1987 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 480 | Denison | 338 | Canton, Ohio |
| 1986 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 496 | Claremont-M-S | 372.5 | Canton, Ohio |
| 1985 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 504 | Claremont-M-S | 409 | Emory |
| 1984 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 429.5 | Claremont-M-S | 169 | Emory |
| 1983 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 336.5 | Claremont-M-S | 194 | Canton, Ohio |
| 1982 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 299 | Williams | 197 | Washington & Lee |
| 1981 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 319 | Johns Hopkins | 272 | Oberlin |
| 1980 | Kenyon | Jim Steen | 323 | Johns Hopkins | 227 | Washington & Jefferson |
| 1979 | Johns Hopkins | Tim Welsh | 340 | Kenyon | 241 | SUNY Geneseo |
| 1978 | Johns Hopkins | Tim Welsh | 284 | Monmouth | 204 | Grinnell |
| 1977 | Johns Hopkins | Frank Comfort | 272 | Occidental | 198 | Oberlin |
| 1976 | St. Lawrence | Scott Woodburn | 249 | Johns Hopkins | 233 | Washington & Jefferson |
| 1975 | Chico State | Ernie Maglischo | 465 | Johns Hopkins | 209 | Allegheny |