| Year | School | Coach | Score | Runner-Up | score | Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | Ashland | Jud Logan | 54 | Angelo State | 53 | Kingsville, TX |
| 2018 | Texas A&M-Kingsville | Ryan Dall | 65 | Ashland | 51 | Charlotte, N.C. |
| 2017 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 58 | Lincoln (MO) | 52 | Bradenton, Florida |
| 2016 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 85 | TAMU-Kingsville/Tiffin | 36 | Bradenton, Florida |
| 2015 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 53 | Findlay | 50 | Grand Valley State |
| 2014 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 112 | Adams State | Grand Valley State | |
| 2013 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 105 | Ashland | 57 | Colorado State-Pueblo |
| 2012 | Adams State | Damon Martin | 77 | Lincoln (Mo.) | 73 | Colorado State-Pueblo |
| 2011 | Abilene Christian | Roosevelt Lofton | 68 | Adams State | 55 | Cal State Stanislaus |
| 2010 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 82 | Abilene Christian | 62 | Johnson C. Smith |
| 2009 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 94 | Abilene Christian | 86 | Angelo State |
| 2008 | Abilene Christian | Don D. Hood | 108 1/2 | St. Augustine's | 102 | Cal Poly Pomona |
| 2007 | Abilene Christian | Don D. Hood | 105 1/2 | St. Augustine's | 73 | Johnson C. Smith |
| 2006 | Abilene Christian | Don D. Hood | 80 | St. Augustine's | Emporia State | |
| 2005 | Abilene Christian | Jon Murray | 109 | Adams State | 84 | Abilene Christian |
| 2004 | Abilene Christian | Jon Murray | 75 | St. Augustine's | 74 | Cal Poly Pomona |
| 2003 | Abilene Christian | Jon Murray | 102 | St. Augustine's | 69 | SIU Edwardsville |
| 2002 | Abilene Christian | Jon Murray | 91 | St. Augustine's | Angelo State | |
| 2001 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 80 | Abilene Christian | SIU Edwardsville | |
| 2000 | Abilene Christian | Jon Murray | 115 | St. Augustine's | St. Augustine's | |
| 1999 | Abilene Christian | Wes Kittley | 93 | St. Augustine's | Emporia State | |
| 1998 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 97 | Abilene Christian | SIU Edwardsville | |
| 1997 | Abilene Christian | Wes Kittley | 151 | Angelo State | SIU Edwardsville | |
| 1996 | Abilene Christian | Wes Kittley | 149 | St. Augustine's | UC Riverside | |
| 1995 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 140 1/2 | Abilene Christian | Emporia State | |
| 1994 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 118 | Abilene Christian | St. Augustine's | |
| 1993 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 116 | Abilene Christian | Abilene Christian | |
| 1992 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 95 | Abilene Christian | Angelo State | |
| 1991 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 120 | Angelo State | Angelo State | |
| 1990 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 111 | Cal State Northridge | Hampton | |
| 1989 | St. Augustine's | George Williams | 107 1/2 | Angelo State | Hampton | |
| 1988 | Abilene Christian | Don Hood | 112 | St. Augustine's | Angelo State | |
| 1987 | Abilene Christian | Don Hood | 127 | Southeastern Missouri State | Southeast Missouri State | |
| 1986 | Abilene Christian | Don Hood | 142 | Southeastern Missouri State | Cal State Los Angeles | |
| 1985 | Abilene Christian | Don Hood | 170 1/2 | Texas A&M-Commerce | Cal State Los Angeles | |
| 1984 | Abilene Christian | Don Hood | 246 | Angelo State | Southeast Missouri State | |
| 1983 | Abilene Christian | Don Hood | 169 1/2 | Angelo State | Southeast Missouri State | |
| 1982 | Abilene Christian | Don Hood | 121 | Cal Poly | Sacramento State | |
| 1981 | Cal Poly | Steve Miller | 92 | Southern Connecticut State | Western Illinois | |
| 1980 | Cal Poly | Steve Miller | 53 | Cal State. Los Angeles | Cal Poly Pomona | |
| 1979 | Cal Poly | Steve Miller | 95 | Cal State Northridge | Western Illinois | |
| 1978 | Cal State Los Angeles | Walt Williamson | 70 | Cal Poly | Western Illinois | |
| 1977 | Cal State East Bay | Jim Santos | 66 | UC Irvine | North Dakota State | |
| 1976 | UC Irvine | Len Miller | 56 | Eastern Illinois | Slippery Rock | |
| 1975 | Cal State Northridge | Clif Abel | 57 | Southeastern Louisiana | Sacramento State | |
| 1974 | Eastern Illinois, Norfolk State | Maynard O'Brien, William Price | 51 | Eastern Illinois | ||
| 1973 | Norfolk State | William Price | 54 | Lincoln (Mo.) | Wabash | |
| 1972 | Eastern Michigan | Bob Parks | 93 | Norfolk State | Ashland | |
| 1971 | Kentucky State | Ken Gibson | 42 | Cal Poly | Sacramento State | |
| 1970 | Cal Poly | Dick Purcell | 49 | C.W. Post | Macalester | |
| 1969 | Cal Poly | Dick Purcell | 76 | Occidental | Ashland | |
| 1968 | Cal Poly | Dick Purcell | 62 | UC Santa Barbara | Cal State East Bay | |
| 1967 | Long Beach State | Jack Rose | 77 | UC Santa Barbara | Weber State | |
| 1966 | San Diego State | Choc Sportsman | 67 | Long Beach State | 56 | Chicago |
| 1965 | San Diego State | Richard Wells | 67 | Luther | 46 | Long Beach State |
| 1964 | Frenso State | Cornelius Warmerdam | 87 | Long Beach State | Fresno State | |
| 1963 | Maryland-Eastern Shore | Clifton Anderson | 98 | Fresno State | Chicago |
