| 2017 |
Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (31-5) |
Kurt Vlasich |
3-0 |
Wittenberg |
Grand Rapids, Michigan |
| 2016 |
Calvin (33-1) |
Amber Warners |
3-0 |
Washington-St. Louis |
Oshkosh, Wisconsin |
| 2015 |
Cal Lutheran (31-5) |
Kellee Roesel |
3-0 |
Wittenberg |
Grand Rapids, Michigan |
| 2014 |
Hope (34-2) |
Becky Schmidt |
3-2 |
Emory |
Newport News, Va. |
| 2013 |
Calvin (35-1) |
Amber Warners |
3-2 |
Cal Lutheran |
Holland, Mich. |
| 2012 |
St. Thomas (Minn.) (40-1) |
Thanh Pham |
3-2 |
Calvin |
Holland, Mich. |
| 2011 |
Wittenberg (37-3) |
Paco Labrador |
3-0 |
Christopher Newport |
Washington-St. Louis |
| 2010 |
Calvin (32-4) |
Amber Warners |
3-1 |
Emory |
Washington-St. Louis |
| 2009 |
Washington-St. Louis (34-4) |
Rich Luenemann |
3-1 |
Juniata |
University Heights, Ohio |
| 2008 |
Emory (35-6) |
Jennifer McDowell |
3-1 |
La Verne |
Ill. Wesleyan |
| 2007 |
Washington-St. Louis (33-5) |
Rich Luenemann |
3-2 |
Wisconsin-Whitewater |
Ill. Wesleyan |
| 2006 |
Juniata (41-1) |
Larry Bock |
3-2 |
Washington-St. Louis |
Salem, Va. |
| 2005 |
Wisconsin-Whitewater (40-4) |
Stacy Boudreau |
3-2 |
Juniata |
Salem, Va. |
| 2004 |
Juniata (37-3) |
Larry Bock |
3-0 |
Washington-St. Louis |
St. Mary's (Minn.) |
| 2003 |
Washington-St. Louis (38-3) |
Rich Luenemann |
3-0 |
New York University |
La Verne |
| 2002 |
Wisconsin-Whitewater (36-4) |
Kris Russell |
3-0 |
Washington-St. Louis |
Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| 2001 |
La Verne (27-1) |
Don Flora |
3-2 |
Wisconsin-Whitewater |
Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| 2000 |
Central (Iowa) (40-2) |
Megan Clayberg |
3-0 |
Wisconsin-Whitewater |
Central (IA) |
| 1999 |
Central (Iowa) (41-0) |
Megan Clayberg |
3-0 |
Trinity (Texas) |
Juniata |
| 1998 |
Central (Iowa) (37-2) |
Megan Clayberg |
3-2 |
UC San Diego |
Juniata |
| 1997 |
UC San Diego (27-5) |
Ducan McFarland |
3-2 |
Juniata |
UC San Diego |
| 1996 |
Washington-St. Louis (43-6) |
Teri Clemens |
3-0 |
Juniata |
Wisconsin-Oshkosh |
| 1995 |
Washington-St. Louis (42-3) |
Teri Clemens |
3-2 |
Cal Lutheran |
Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| 1994 |
Washington-St. Louis (42-2) |
Teri Clemens |
3-0 |
Wisconsin-Oshkosh |
Ithaca |
| 1993 |
Washington-St. Louis (40-2) |
Teri Clemens |
3-0 |
Juniata |
Juniata |
| 1992 |
Washington-St. Louis (40-0) |
Teri Clemens |
3-0 |
UC San Diego |
Washington-St. Louis |
| 1991 |
Washington-St. Louis (42-4) |
Teri Clemens |
3-2 |
UC San Diego |
Washington-St. Louis |
| 1990 |
UC San Diego (37-8) |
Doug Dannevik |
3-2 |
Washington-St. Louis |
Washington-St. Louis |
| 1989 |
Washington-St. Louis (39-6) |
Teri Clemens |
3-0 |
Ohio Northern |
Washington-St. Louis |
| 1988 |
UC San Diego (34-8) |
Doug Dannevik |
3-2 |
Benedictine (Ill.) |
UC San Diego |
| 1987 |
UC San Diego (31-4) |
Doug Dannevik |
3-0 |
Elmhusrt |
Elmhurst |
| 1986 |
UC San Diego (42-6) |
Doug Dannevik |
3-2 |
Calvin |
Calvin |
| 1985 |
Elmhurst (40-9) |
Bill Walton |
3-0 |
La Verne |
Elmhurst |
| 1984 |
UC San Diego (23-12) |
Doug Dannevik |
3-0 |
MIT |
Elmhurst |
| 1983 |
Elmhurst (57-4) |
Bill Walton |
3-1 |
UC San Diego |
La Verne |
| 1982 |
La Verne (30-10) |
Jim Paschal |
3-1 |
UC San Diego |
UC San Diego |
| 1981 |
UC San Diego (36-8) |
Doug Dannevik |
3-2 |
Juniata |
Maryville (Tenn.) |