| Year | Champion (Record) | Coach | Score | Runner-Up | Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2018 | Emory (30-6) |
Jenny McDowell |
3-0 | Calvin | Pittsburgh, Penn. |
| 2017 | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (31-5) | Kurt Vlasich | 3-0 | Wittenberg | Grand Rapids, Michigan |
| 2016 | Calvin (33-1) | Amber Warners | 3-0 | Washington-St. Louis | Oshkosh, Wisconsin |
| 2015 | Cal Lutheran (31-5) | Kellee Roesel | 3-0 | Wittenberg | Grand Rapids, Michigan |
| 2014 | Hope (34-2) | Becky Schmidt | 3-2 | Emory | Newport News, Va. |
| 2013 | Calvin (35-1) | Amber Warners | 3-2 | Cal Lutheran | Holland, Mich. |
| 2012 | St. Thomas (Minn.) (40-1) | Thanh Pham | 3-2 | Calvin | Holland, Mich. |
| 2011 | Wittenberg (37-3) | Paco Labrador | 3-0 | Christopher Newport | Washington-St. Louis |
| 2010 | Calvin (32-4) | Amber Warners | 3-1 | Emory | Washington-St. Louis |
| 2009 | Washington-St. Louis (34-4) | Rich Luenemann | 3-1 | Juniata | University Heights, Ohio |
| 2008 | Emory (35-6) | Jennifer McDowell | 3-1 | La Verne | Ill. Wesleyan |
| 2007 | Washington-St. Louis (33-5) | Rich Luenemann | 3-2 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | Ill. Wesleyan |
| 2006 | Juniata (41-1) | Larry Bock | 3-2 | Washington-St. Louis | Salem, Va. |
| 2005 | Wisconsin-Whitewater (40-4) | Stacy Boudreau | 3-2 | Juniata | Salem, Va. |
| 2004 | Juniata (37-3) | Larry Bock | 3-0 | Washington-St. Louis | St. Mary's (Minn.) |
| 2003 | Washington-St. Louis (38-3) | Rich Luenemann | 3-0 | New York University | La Verne |
| 2002 | Wisconsin-Whitewater (36-4) | Kris Russell | 3-0 | Washington-St. Louis | Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| 2001 | La Verne (27-1) | Don Flora | 3-2 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| 2000 | Central (Iowa) (40-2) | Megan Clayberg | 3-0 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | Central (IA) |
| 1999 | Central (Iowa) (41-0) | Megan Clayberg | 3-0 | Trinity (Texas) | Juniata |
| 1998 | Central (Iowa) (37-2) | Megan Clayberg | 3-2 | UC San Diego | Juniata |
| 1997 | UC San Diego (27-5) | Ducan McFarland | 3-2 | Juniata | UC San Diego |
| 1996 | Washington-St. Louis (43-6) | Teri Clemens | 3-0 | Juniata | Wisconsin-Oshkosh |
| 1995 | Washington-St. Louis (42-3) | Teri Clemens | 3-2 | Cal Lutheran | Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| 1994 | Washington-St. Louis (42-2) | Teri Clemens | 3-0 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | Ithaca |
| 1993 | Washington-St. Louis (40-2) | Teri Clemens | 3-0 | Juniata | Juniata |
| 1992 | Washington-St. Louis (40-0) | Teri Clemens | 3-0 | UC San Diego | Washington-St. Louis |
| 1991 | Washington-St. Louis (42-4) | Teri Clemens | 3-2 | UC San Diego | Washington-St. Louis |
| 1990 | UC San Diego (37-8) | Doug Dannevik | 3-2 | Washington-St. Louis | Washington-St. Louis |
| 1989 | Washington-St. Louis (39-6) | Teri Clemens | 3-0 | Ohio Northern | Washington-St. Louis |
| 1988 | UC San Diego (34-8) | Doug Dannevik | 3-2 | Benedictine (Ill.) | UC San Diego |
| 1987 | UC San Diego (31-4) | Doug Dannevik | 3-0 | Elmhusrt | Elmhurst |
| 1986 | UC San Diego (42-6) | Doug Dannevik | 3-2 | Calvin | Calvin |
| 1985 | Elmhurst (40-9) | Bill Walton | 3-0 | La Verne | Elmhurst |
| 1984 | UC San Diego (23-12) | Doug Dannevik | 3-0 | MIT | Elmhurst |
| 1983 | Elmhurst (57-4) | Bill Walton | 3-1 | UC San Diego | La Verne |
| 1982 | La Verne (30-10) | Jim Paschal | 3-1 | UC San Diego | UC San Diego |
| 1981 | UC San Diego (36-8) | Doug Dannevik | 3-2 | Juniata | Maryville (Tenn.) |