This is the latest in our series of all time starting nines for some of college baseball’s most successful programs. Players' professional careers were not considered, just their college careers — along with consideration given to their positional fits as well as a batting order that could provide a combination of a high batting average, speed and power.
1. Jeff Guiel (1996-97) – Outfield
Guiel is one of three players in Oklahoma State history to be named a First Team All-American in multiple seasons, along with Robin Ventura and Pete Incaviglia. He is second in program history in career batting average (.406) and third in career slugging percentage (.771).
In 1996, the outfielder hit .394 with 17 doubles, 15 home runs, 80 RBI, a .516 on-base percentage and 27 steals. He managed to improve in most statistical categories the following season, batting .418 with 105 hits, a Big 12-record 32 doubles, 23 home runs, 79 RBI, an .845 slugging percentage that ranks fifth in program history, a .519 on-base percentage, and 212 total bases – the fourth-best single-season total by a Cowboys player. He was inducted into the OSU Hall of Fame in 2015.
2. Monty Fariss (1986-88) – Shortstop
Fariss shared the left side of Oklahoma State's infield in the late 1980s with Robin Ventura, the Oklahoma State legend and 16-year MLB veteran, and amazingly, Fariss actually had better numbers in 1988, when Ventura was named national player of the year. During his First Team All-American campaign as a junior, Fariss hit .397 with a team-high 30 home runs and an NCAA-best 114 RBI, while producing a ridiculous .860 slugging percentage that ranks as the third-best single-season percentage in program history. He was also a master at getting on base, as seen by his .571 on-base percentage as a junior.
Fariss was inducted into the Oklahoma State Hall of Fame in 1994 after finishing his career second in Cowboys history in walks (224), third in home runs (65) and RBI (247), fourth in runs (268), and sixth in slugging percentage (.706) and total bases (489).
3. Robin Ventura (1986-88) – Third base
Ventura is the best player in Oklahoma State history, a three-time First Team All-American who was named The Sporting News Player of the Year twice and won the Golden Spikes Award in 1988. He holds program records for career batting average (.428), hits (329), runs (300), set an NCAA record with a 58-game hitting streak, and he ranks second in school history in doubles (71), home runs (68), RBI (302), total bases (608), and career slugging percentage (.792). He is a member of both the Oklahoma State Hall of Fame and National College Baseball Hall of Fame.
Ventura was an other-worldly talent from the moment he stepped foot on campus, batting an OSU-record .469 with 21 home runs and 96 RBI with an .846 slugging percentage and .587 on-base percentage. He was good for a .390-plus batting average, 100-plus hits, at least 20 home runs, 90-plus RBI, at least 60 walks, and an on-base percentage well over .500.
As a junior, when he won the Golden Spikes Award, Ventura hit .391 with 26 home runs and 96 RBI, a .766 slugging percentage, .530 on-base percentage, 61 walks, 96 runs and 11 game-winning hits.
4. Pete Incaviglia (1983-85) – Outfield
There are countless school, conference and NCAA records set by Incaviglia that could be used to describe the historic nature of his college career but perhaps the best way to introduce him to this list is the following: Baseball America named Incaviglia college baseball's player of the century in 1999. Think about that for a moment. Of all of the thousands of players who played college baseball in the 1900s, the publication named Incaviglia the best of them all.
He set five NCAA records, four of which were single-season marks set in 1985, when he hit 48 home runs, knocked in 143 runs, compiled 285 total bases and produced an absurd 1.140 slugging percentage. He hit .464 that season with 21 doubles, 80 walks and 98 runs. He was once intentionally walked five times in one game against Wichita State, which shows just how feared of a hitter he was in college. Incaviglia's 48 single-season home runs are 18 more than the second-best single-season mark in Cowboys history and his 143 RBI are 29 more than the next-best total by an OSU player.
His 100 career home runs are an NCAA record and he set seven Big Eight records, in addition to being named a three-time All-American and two-time College World Series All-Tournament Team honoree. We could go on forever about Incaviglia's accomplishments, but we'll end on this – in his worst college season, he hit .371 with 23 home runs and 78 RBI.
5. Jimmy Barragan (1985-87) – First base
Barragan rounds out Oklahoma State's all-time starting infield to give the 1980s Cowboys a trio of players who were teammates in Stillwater. Like Fariss and Ventura, the two-time All-American and Oklahoma State Hall of Fame first baseman is among the best power hitters in school history. Barragan ranks fourth in career hits (279), sixth in home runs (54), RBI (231), and total bases (489), ninth in runs (216) and 10th in career average (.377). Defensively, he was strong at first, recording a fielding percentage of at least .988 every season, including a career-best .995 percentage as a sophomore.
Barragan's .420 batting average as a sophomore ranks 13th in program history, his 105 hits that season are the fifth-most ever by a Cowboys player, his 24 home runs are the eighth-most in a single season, his 91 runs batted in ranks 12th, and he once got a hit in eight consecutive at-bats. As a junior, Barragan was named to the College World Series All-Tournament Team, capping off another impressive season in which he batted .371 with 21 home runs and 85 RBI.
6. Tyler Mach (2006-07) – Second base
We're exercising some creative freedom with this choice. Mach, who started his career at Washington and spent a season at Edmonds Community College, played for Oklahoma State for two seasons – the first of which he played third base. Mach played second base in 2007 and Robin Ventura, you know, the two-time Sporting News Player of the Year and three-time First Team All-American, is a no-brainer for OSU's all-time starting third baseman position.
A 2x All-American, a Big 12 Player of the Year award, 191 hits, 32 HR, 147 RBIs & a .375 batting average — Tyler Mach made the most of his 2 seasons at #okstate and is the newest member of the Cowboy Baseball HOF! Congrats Tyler! pic.twitter.com/HyrMEiFFp5— Cowboy Baseball (@OSUBaseball) November 30, 2017
After his first season in Stillwater, Mach was named Co-Big 12 Player of the Year and Big 12 Newcomer of the Year after leading the Cowboys in the following categories: .364 batting average, 91 hits, 18 doubles, 16 home runs, and 66 RBI. The two-time All-American followed up his debut season with Oklahoma State with an even better encore. He hit .386 with 100 hits, 24 doubles, 16 home runs, and 81 RBI. He was inducted into the Oklahoma State Hall of Fame this year.
7. Michael Daniel (1990-91) – Catcher
Despite playing for Oklahoma State for just two seasons, Daniel left Stillwater, Okla., as one of the best Cowboys power-hitters ever. He earned Second Team All-American honors both seasons, leaving Oklahoma State with 50 home runs (eighth all-time) and 199 RBI (10th all-time), along with a career .770 slugging percentage that ranks fourth in program history.
Not only did he lead the Cowboys in both home runs and RBI in 1990 (23 home runs, 92 RBI) and 1991 (27 home runs, 107 RBI), but Daniel led the NCAA in runs batted in during both seasons and homers in '91. However, Daniel wasn't just a one-trick pony. He was able to hit for average – .362 in 1990, .350 in 1991 – and he had an on-base percentage in the .480s both seasons, showing his patience at the plate.
Daniel was named to the College World Series All-Tournament Team in 1990 and he was inducted into the Oklahoma State Hall of fame in 1994.
8. Rusty McNamara (1995-97) – Outfield
With apologies to Corey Brown, who also deserved serious consideration for the third outfield spot, we went with McNamara, who was inductd into the Oklahoma State Hall of Fame in 2015. After his three-year career with the Cowboys, he ranks sixth in career hits (277), seventh in runs (240), eighth in RBI (205) and total bases (477), and 10th in home runs (45). His numbers improved each season: .315 with two home runs and 26 RBI as a freshman, to .362 with 19 home runs and 89 RBI as a sophomore, to his All-American campaign as a junior when he hit .387 with 24 home runs and 93 RBI.
He had two 100-plus hit seasons, including a 101-hit, 100-run season as a sophomore, when he led the NCAA in runs scored in 1996. You can find McNamara's name in OSU's record book among the top-10 single-season record-holders for hits, doubles, home runs, runs, and total bases.
9. Dennis Livingston (1982-84) – Pitcher
As a sophomore in 1983, Livingston was named a First Team All-American by Baseball America after going 15-3 in 19 starts, with eight complete games, while striking out a Big Eight and school-record 180 batters with an ERA of 3.00. In the span of less than a month, he threw a no-hitter against Kansas State and a pair of one-hitters. That season came after a freshman campaign in which he was named a Third Team All-American after going 8-2 with a team-low 2.29 ERA, 77 strikeouts in 55 innings, and 10 saves, which is the second-best single-season total in program history.
Livingston then won 10 games as a junior, finishing his career tied for first in school history in wins (33), first in complete games (21), second in strikeouts (344), and third in saves (14). The lefty was as strong and as durable of a starting pitcher as the Cowboys have seen, while being a lights-out closer as a freshman, and he was a strikeout extraordinaire in both roles.
Gary Ward (1978-1996) – Coach
Ward is responsible for 10 of Oklahoma State's 20 College World Series appearances, including seven consecutive appearances in the 1980s. The Cowboys were the national runners-up in 1981, 1987 and 1990. He was a four-time Big Eight Coach of the Year, an award that no other coach won more than once, and he led the team to 17 NCAA regional appearances.