basketball-men-d1 flag

Joe Boozell | | December 6, 2016

New Big East isn't the old Big East, but still awfully good

  Villanova is the biggest name, but the Big East has quality depth behind the Wildcats.

The ‘new Big East’ formed in 2013, and at the time, it kind of just felt like a hodgepodge of basketball programs thrown together on a whim. There were the old Big East holdovers like Villanova, Georgetown, St. John’s and Seton Hall, but new schools also joined the fray in Xavier, Butler and Creighton.

What would this conference’s identity be? It would take years to find out, along with some soul-searching. The tales of the old Big East are legendary – the games were so physical that often times, they resembled a different sport entirely.

That is most certainly not the Big East’s identity in 2016. But in the midst of its fourth full season, perhaps this conference doesn’t care about its reputation anymore. It just wins, and people will ultimately say what they’re going to say about them.

MORE: Villanova jumps to No. 1 in newest AP Poll

The Big East is notably absent from the list of Power Five conferences as we know them. But it was also never a mid-major. The past few years, it’s just sort of existed in its own world – the Big East featured some quality teams, but until any of them made real noise in the NCAA tournament, it would just sort of be. That’s intentionally abstract. Going into the 2015-16 season, the league still hadn’t carved out its niche. And then:

You can’t overstate how important Villanova’s national championship was to the Big East, but the truth is, top to bottom, the Wildcats played in one of the better conferences in the country last season. Xavier had its best season in years. So did Seton Hall. Butler maintained its level of consistency, and Providence had two of the top 20 players in America. The Wildcats dominated the league in the regular season, but all of these schools put up a fight.

Villanova’s incredible title run simply made people notice what was happening in the new Big East. So this season presented a fork in the road for the league: with new eyeballs on it, would the Big East show that it’s more than a Villanova feasting ground? Or would other teams jump into the public spectrum?

The answer, overwhelmingly, has been the latter.

The Big East’s top four teams are a sparkling 31-1 on the season, and each has bested at least one powerful program from another conference.

Villanova owns a win against Purdue on the road. And frankly, the Boilermakers are a terrible matchup for the Wildcats. Purdue’s strength is its massive front line of Isaac Haas and Caleb Swanigan; Darryl Reynolds is Villanova’s only true big, and the Cats played the 6-6 Jenkins extensive minutes at center. Dominant post players are supposed to be the Wildcats’ kryptonite.

It didn’t matter. Villanova scored gutsy win in West Lafayette, and beyond that, the Wildcats haven’t really been challenged. Josh Hart has an expanded role this season, and he’s responded well. Jenkins is better than he was last year. So is Jalen Brunson. And if you’re a ball-handler and Mikal Bridges is guarding you, just save yourself the trouble and pass to a teammate. It’s not worth the hassle.

RELATED: Hart a name to watch in Naismith race

Creighton is scoring the ball at a crazy-good rate. The Bluejays are averaging 90.8 points per game, which ranks fifth in the country. Greg McDermott no longer has a Missouri Valley Conference roster propped up by his son Doug; these guys were recruited to play in the Big East, and they’re thriving in McDermott’s wide-open system.

Six Bluejays average eight points per game or more, and the backcourt of Marcus Foster and Mo Watson, Jr. is elite. Creighton defeated Wisconsin earlier this season by double digits, and it took down three other power conference schools (Washington State, North Carolina State and Ole Miss) with relative ease.

Then there is Xavier, which hasn’t had as good of a start as it hoped for in 2016-17. With that said, the Musketeers are still 7-1, and their one setback came on the road against No. 4 Baylor. That’s about as good of a loss as you’ll find.

Xavier needs more from its frontcourt – Trevon Bluiett and Edmond Sumner have been as good as advertised, but the Musketeers miss Jalen Reynolds and James Farr, and their replacements have struggled. If Chris Mack can salvage a bit more out of his big guys, Xavier can still challenge Villanova for the Big East crown.

There are similarities between No. 10 Creighton and a team a few spots down in the rankings, Butler. The Bulldogs might have their deepest roster ever, and Kelan Martin is a star. Kamar Baldwin looks like he’s on his way to becoming one. Butler notched an impressive win against shorthanded Arizona, but perhaps its true road triumph against Utah two nights later was even more impressive. The Utes lost one home game last season, and though Jakob Poeltl is gone, that’s an incredibly difficult place to win.

The Bulldogs have been tested time and time again against potential tournament teams (Northwestern, Arizona, Utah) and they’ve yet to flinch.

And don’t look now, but Marquette is the No. 30 team in KenPom as it stands today. The Golden Eagles smoked Vanderbilt out of the SEC in their first game, and they recently scored an impressive road win at Georgia. JaJuan Johnson is one of the most improved players in the country, Luke Fischer is solid as always, and Haanif Cheatham is undervalued. Look out for these guys.

At the start of this piece, I mentioned that it would take years for the new Big East to find its identity. Turns out, that might not be the case. Winning is ultimately the best way to silence doubters, but the style in which these programs are doing so is pretty shocking considering what the Big East used to be.

That was, among other things: Physical defense. Post play. Diving on the floor for loose balls. Using every second on the shot clock.

Now? Offense, baby.

Big East offense vs. defense Division I ranking
Team Adjusted Offensive Rating Adjusted Defensive Rating
Villanova 2 9
Butler 21 17
Xavier 18 23
Creighton 9 74
Marquette 20 55
Seton Hall 44 59

The Big East is really good again, for entirely different reasons than it used to be. Outside of the ACC, there might not be a better or more entertaining conference in college basketball this season.

November FCS games that will impact conference title races and the playoffs

Let’s look at some key games to watch in the final month of the FCS regular season.

Top 10 Final Four dark horses in the 2023-24 men's college basketball season, according to Andy Katz

Here are 10 dark horses to make the 2024 Final Four according to Andy Katz.

The top 10 super seniors in the 2023-24 men's college basketball season, according to Andy Katz

Here are the top 10 super seniors to watch for the upcoming men's college basketball season.

Subscribe To Email Updates

Enter your information to receive emails about offers, promotions from and our partners