basketball-men-d1 flag

Jim Polzin | January 2, 2018

Evaluating the Big Ten heading into a new year

Wisconsin has a lot of ground to make up as they resume conference play with a game against Indiana.

There were plenty of missed opportunities during non-conference play for Big Ten Conference men's basketball teams.

The Big Ten went 22-31 -- a .415 winning percentage -- against opponents from the five other major conferences. No team took it on the chin harder than the University of Wisconsin, which went 0-5 against teams in that category and was the only Big Ten team not to record a win against a team from a group that includes the ACC, Big East, Big Eight, Pac-12 and SEC.

The Badgers (8-7, 1-1 Big Ten) have a lot of ground to make up as they resume conference play with a game against Indiana (8-6, 1-1) Tuesday night at the Kohl Center.

MORE: Xavier vs. Butler, full slate of Big Ten games highlight action-packed Tuesday

But UW certainly is not alone in that regard.

Here's a look at where Big Ten teams stand at the midway point of the season:


Record: 10-5, 0-2 Big Ten

John Groce left the cupboard pretty bare for Brad Underwood, who has the Fighting Illini playing faster but doesn't have the firepower to compete with good teams. All three of Illinois' non-conference losses were to KenPom Top 100 teams, but Underwood and Co. are lacking signature wins.


Record: 8-6, 1-1 Big Ten

The Hoosiers, under first-year coach Archie Miller, are bad defensively and struggle from the free throw line and 3-point range. They already have two bad home losses on their resume: by 21 points to Indiana State and by 20 points to Fort Wayne. If not for an upset win over Notre Dame in overtime, the first half of the season would have been a total disaster for Indiana. As with Underwood at Illinois, Miller walked into an unfavorable situation left by Tom Crean.


Record: 9-6, 0-2 Big Ten

The Hawkeyes are 0-6 against teams in the KenPom Top 100. They finished in seventh place of eight teams at a tournament in the Cayman Islands in November, opening the event with losses to Louisiana-Lafayette and South Dakota State. Iowa is still a relatively young team despite returning most of its rotation, but this was a team some thought could contend for a top-four spot in the Big Ten standings.

Katz's Power 36: Who's in the NCAA tournament 


Record: 12-3, 1-1 Big Ten

The Terrapins ended 2017 with two pieces of bad news on the injury front. After losing starting forward Justin Jackson to a season-ending right shoulder injury, Maryland found out another member of the rotation, junior forward Ivan Bender, will miss the rest of the season with a right knee injury. Jackson, who was averaging 9.8 points and a team-leading 8.1 rebounds, is a huge loss. The Terrapins have a top-20 defense, but their offense has been plagued by turnovers. They average 16.5 per game, the most in the Big Ten.


Record: 12-3,1-1 Big Ten

After splitting a pair of Big Ten games to open the month of December, Michigan recorded resume-building wins over UCLA and Texas, the latter on the road. Sophomore guard Charles Matthews (16.1 ppg), a transfer from Kentucky, has formed a nice 1-2 punch with junior forward Moritz Wagner (14.9 ppg). Michigan is No. 24 in the KenPom adjusted defensive efficiency ratings, which would be its best finish under John Beilein.

MORE: College basketball's weekly honors led by Arizona's Deandre Ayton, Butler's big win and more

Michigan State

Record: 14-1, 2-0 Big Ten

The Spartans' only loss was to Duke in the second game of the season. They have double-digit wins over North Carolina and Notre Dame, though Michigan State's schedule has been filled with cupcakes since that Nov. 30 win over the Fighting Irish. The Spartans have stars -- sophomores Miles Bridges (17.0 ppg, 7.8 rpg) and Nick Ward (15.4 ppg, 7.5 rpg) lead the way -- and depth. They have a legitimate chance to become the first Big Ten team to win a national championship since Tom Izzo led Michigan State to the 2000 title.


Record: 12-3, 1-1 Big Ten

The Gophers were hoping to contend for a Big Ten title after a breakthrough season in 2016-17. That may still happen, but a 78-68 loss at Nebraska in Dec. 5 was a bit of a head-scratcher. Depth is an issue for Minnesota. So is a lack of consistency, though Jordan Murphy can't be tagged with that label. The junior forward has recorded a double-double in every game this season and leads the Big Ten in scoring (19.1) and rebounding (12.6).


Record: 10-5, 1-1 Big Ten

Transfers James Palmer Jr. (15.1 ppg) and Isaac Copeland (12.1 ppg) have added some much-needed scoring and athleticism to the Nebraska lineup. But the Cornhuskers are going to have a difficult time in the Big Ten if they can't do a better job on the glass. Opponents are collecting 33.6 percent of their misses against Nebraska.


Record: 10-5, 1-1 Big Ten

The Wildcats returned eight of the top 10 scorers from a team that advanced to the NCAA tournament for the first time in program history. But they've gone backward this season, particularly on defense. They have a pair of blowout losses on their resume: 85-49 against Texas Tech, and 104-78 against Oklahoma. Northwestern's only KenPom Top 100 win was at home in overtime against Illinois.

MORE: Balanced MAC should provide plenty of regular season drama

Ohio State

Record: 11-4, 2-0 Big Ten

The Buckeyes don't have many great wins thus far, but they don't have any bad defeats, either. All in all, Chris Holtmann has done a great job after being hired to replace Thad Matta in June. Junior forward Keita Bates-Diop has been great after missing most of last season with a leg injury. He's third in the Big Ten in scoring (18.7) and rebounding (8.7).

Penn State

Record: 11-4, 1-1 Big Ten

The Nittany Lions are 1-3 against KenPom Top 100 teams, including a home loss to UW. They also lost at home to Rider, a brutal defeat for a program that has the talent to contend for an NCAA tournament berth. Penn State is solid on defense, but it's erratic on the other end of the court. Sophomore guard Tony Carr is a big reason for that; while he's second in the Big Ten in scoring (18.9 ppg), he went a combined 8 of 36 from the field in the losses to UW and Rider.

College basketball rankings: Michigan State the new No. 1; Oklahoma rises | Poll


Record: 13-2, 2-0 Big Ten

The Boilermakers opened the Battle 4 Atlantis in November with losses to Tennessee and Western Kentucky, setting up a high-profile matchup against Arizona for seventh place. But Purdue beat the Wildcats to start an impressive run that included wins over Louisville, Maryland, Northwestern and Butler. Sophomore point guard Carsen Edwards (17.7 ppg) has taken a big jump since last season and has a solid group of veterans around him. If anybody is going to give Michigan State a run for the Big Ten title, it's Matt Painter's team.


Record: 10-5, 0-2 Big Ten

The Scarlet Knights were competitive in home losses to Florida State and Michigan State, and they opened eyes by knocking off visiting Seton Hall on Dec. 16. How did Rutgers follow up that victory over the Pirates? By losing at home to Stony Brook and Hartford in the span of a week. The Scarlet Knights play hard under coach Steve Pikiell and are relentless on the offensive glass. But poor shooting -- 41.7 percent overall, 29.2 percent from 3-point range and 61.6 percent from the free throw line -- has plagued Rutgers.

MORE: 68 fearless college basketball predictions for the rest of the season


Record: 8-7, 1-1 Big Ten

A tough early season schedule provided a chance for a young team to grow. Instead, a series of close losses destroyed the Badgers' confidence. Injuries in the backcourt to Kobe King and D'Mitrik Trice have left Greg Gard with a depleted rotation that includes walk-ons. Getting to the NIT would be an achievement for UW at this point. But even that's going to be difficult for a team that is allowing opponents to shoot 45.9 percent from the field. 

This article is written by Jim Polzin from The Wisconsin State Journal and was legally licensed via the Tribune Content Agency through the NewsCred publisher network. Please direct all licensing questions to


Andy Katz ranks his 10 best playmakers ahead of the 2023-2024 men's college basketball season

Andy Katz ranks the 10 best playmakers in college basketball ahead of the men's college basketball season.

Men's basketball NIT names new committee members

Morgan State Vice President and Director of Athletics Dena Freeman-Patton and Western Athletic Conference Commissioner Brian Thornton have been added to the National Invitation Tournament committee.

Andy Katz ranks top 10 rivalries in men's college basketball for the 2023-24 season

With fewer than six weeks remaining until college basketball tips-off, NCAA Digital's Andy Katz takes a look at the ten best rivalry matchups for the 2023-24 season.

Subscribe To Email Updates

Enter your information to receive emails about offers, promotions from and our partners