basketball-men-d1 flag

Joe Boozell | | January 8, 2018

AP reactions: Nova back at No. 1; West Virginia climbs

Seton Hall Basketball: Angel Delgado | Player of the Week

What a college basketball week that was. As expected, there were some serious changes in the new AP Top 25. The full poll:

1 Villanova (52) 14-1 1,611 3
2 West Virginia (12) 14-1 1,559 6
3 Virginia (1) 14-1 1,438 8
4 Michigan State 15-2 1,390 1
T-5 Wichita State 13-2 1,225 9
T-5 Purdue 15-2 1,225 13
7 Duke 13-2 1,222 2
8 Texas Tech 14-1 1,174 18
9 Oklahoma 12-2 1,152 7
10 Xavier 15-2 1,050 5
11 Arizona State 13-2 1,036 4
12 Kansas 12-3 888 10
13 Seton Hall 14-2 759 21
14 Cincinnati 14-2 739 T-19
15 Gonzaga 14-3 676 T-19
16 TCU 13-2 621 16
17 Arizona 12-4 537 14
18 Miami (FL) 13-2 502 15
19 Clemson 14-1 465 25
20 North Carolina 12-4 423 12
21 Kentucky 12-3 314 17
22 Auburn 14-1 243 NR
23 Florida State 12-3 202 24
24 Tennessee 10-4 198 23
25 Creighton 13-3 160 NR

The reason for shakeup? Let’s sum it up with emojis:

Eleven teams from last week’s AP Top 25 lost over the weekend, so here we are: just one team -- No. 16 TCU -- has the same ranking as it did last week.

Villanova is back at No. 1, which was expected. Of the top-ranked teams to fall this season – the Wildcats, Duke and Michigan State – Villanova’s loss is the most easily justified. Its defeat to Butler came on the road, and the Bulldogs shot 15-for-22 from 3; the Wildcats still only lost by eight. The Blue Devils lost to Boston College, and the Spartans weren’t competitive against Ohio State. To be clear, there are no juggernauts in college basketball this season. But right now, Villanova is the best of the bunch.

No. 2 West Virginia and No. 3 Virginia aren’t far behind. The Mountaineers are the hottest team in America, having won their last 14 games after a season-opening loss to Texas A&M. Teams they’ve beaten since: Oklahoma, Virginia, Kansas State, Oklahoma State, Missouri. Jevon Carter is the only guy who’s given Trae Young serious fits this season; he’s West Virginia’s best player, and a true two-way beast.

But the reason this Mountaineer squad is better than Bob Huggins’ past teams? The offense isn’t lagging too far behind the defense – West Virginia ranks 24th on O and 12th on D. This would be the Mountaineers’ best offense since 2013-14 (but they finished 135th on defense that year – it was before the Press Virginia days).

Here’s the thing, though: West Virginia plays in the Big 12, the best league in the country. It’s probably going to lose a tough road game soon. So don’t freak out when that happens. This is the most well-rounded group we’ve seen in the Huggins era, and a setback against a worthy foe shouldn’t cause panic. There’s so much parity this year that it’s inevitable.  

MORE: Andy Katz's Power 36

Virginia checks in at No. 3, and the Cavaliers have doubled down on their identity – they rank first in defense and last in pace. If the season ended today, Virginia would finish decimal points away from being the best defense of the KenPom era – Memphis had an 84.2 defensive rating in 2008-09; UVA is at 84.4 now. The defense is better than ever, and Ty Jerome and Kyle Guy have upped the Cavs’ risk profile. They bringe an explosive element that past Virginia teams have lacked.

Tony Bennett has to break through in March at some point. Stop us if you’ve heard this before, but this could be the year.

How crazy was this week? No. 5 Purdue rose eight spots, and all it did was beat Rutgers and Nebraska. Wichita State (tied with Purdue for fifth) rose four spots by beating Houston and South Florida. No. 8 Texas Tech jumped 10 spots – but the Red Raiders beat Kansas on the road, so that’s more easily explained. Perhaps most shocking of all: the Jayhawks actually rose two spots despite losing at home to Texas Tech. Keep in mind, Texas Tech had never beaten Kansas in Lawrence. The Jayhawks rebounded with a nice win at TCU, but that just proves how much chaos occurred in the top 10.

A few other notes: Duke dropped five spots to No. 7 after losing at N.C. State. The Blue Devils’ defense remains a huge problem; stuff like this will keep happening until it gets fixed. Duke has the No. 1 offense and the No. 108 defense. Seton Hall rose eight spots to No. 13 after a comeback win at Butler; the Pirates are experienced, talented, and play a physical style that travels well. Clemson is a stealth ACC contender; the No. 19 Tigers are 14-1, and with Duke and North Carolina struggling, the league title may be more attainable than usual (granted, right now, it’s Virginia’s to lose). The SEC doesn’t have a great team, but has plenty of solid ones – Kentucky, Auburn and Tennessee are all ranked in the 20s.

At this point, would any team losing a conference road game be that much of a surprise? No. And that’s why college basketball is worth watching every night. We know more crazy stuff will go down this week. The key is knowing where to look, which is darn near impossible.

And that’s fun. Bring on more madness in January.

10 lessons learned in this year's men's college basketball attendance numbers

Attendance numbers are out and they are telling a different side of the story that was the 2022-23 men's college basketball season.

Every HBCU player ever selected in the NBA Draft

A complete history of HBCU players in the NBA draft, including the 351 HBCU men's basketball players selected since 1950.

Remembering Denny Crum, from Wizard’s apprentice to the hall of fame

Denny Crum and Louisville are forever paired, writes Mike Lopresti, but it could have been different for the guard who played for John Wooden in the 1950s and coached alongside him through the 60s.

Subscribe To Email Updates

Enter your information to receive emails about offers, promotions from and our partners