basketball-women-d1 flag

Autumn Johnson | May 17, 2021

How Paige Bueckers’ freshman season compares to other all-time greats

Paige Bueckers 2021 NCAA tournament highlights

We've seen many stand-out freshman performances in women's college basketball history, but the constant buzz Paige Bueckers created throughout the entire 2020-21 season put the nation on notice — even before she put on a Huskie jersey. 

Bueckers became the new face of women's college basketball after Sabrina Ionescu was drafted to the WNBA as the No. 1 overall pick. Bueckers owned that spotlight every night.

She led her team to the Final Four and was the Naismith Player of the Year. She's the first freshman POY in the 39-year history of the award and fourth first-year player ever, following men’s winners Kevin Durant (2007), Anthony Davis (2012) and Zion Williamson (2019). 

This struck our curiosity to see how Bueckers' freshmen year matched up to other all-time greats in their first year. It's not a stretch to say she had the best freshman college basketball season by an individual, ever.

I compared her first-year stats to Tamika Catchings (Tennessee), Cheryl Miller (Southern California), Chamique Holdsclaw (Tennessee), Katie Smith (Ohio State), Sabrina Ionescu (Oregon) and fellow Huskies Maya Moore and Breanna Stewart. All had remarkable freshman seasons. I chose these players based on several factors, including some who went on to win the Naismith Award later in their careers.

Bueckers led UConn in points, three-point percentage, steals and assists. Here's where she stands, stats-wise, against the legends listed above:

PLAYER — Freshman season GP PPG Points 3-pt % Assists steals
Paige Bueckers (G) — 2020-21 29 20.0  581 .464 5.8 66
Tamika Catchings (F) — 1997-98  39 18.2 711 .364 2.6 100
Chamique Holdsclaw (F)  — 1995-96 36 16.2 583 .233 2.1 34
Cheryl Miller (F) — 1982-83 33 20.4 673 N/A  3.5 115
Maya Moore (G) — 2007-08 38 17.8 678 .430 3.1 63
Katie Smith (G/F) — 1992-93 32 18.1 578 N/A 3.3 59
Breanna Stewart (F) — 2012-13 36 13.8 497 .333 1.0 41
Sabrina Ionescu (G)  — 2016-17 33 14.6 420 .420 5.5 44

Bueckers' name has been mentioned in many conversations with these greats. Comparisons to Diana Taurasi's iconic junior and senior year were made when it came to discussing Bueckers' relentless ability to score, confidence and even swag on the court. 

Moore and Bueckers' names have been mentioned in the same sentence more than once 2020-21 season. Most notably, when Bueckers scored 30-plus points in three consecutive games, breaking Moore's record. Bueckers and Moore are the only Big East players who can say they have earned the conference's player- and freshman-of-the-year honors in the same season. 

Bueckers, the "walking highlight," is known for her vision and crafty ability to pass to her teammates. Bueckers set the UConn single-game assist record, dishing out 14 against Butler on Feb. 27. Bueckers was the season record holder amongst all Huskies for assists with 168. Amongst the greats listed above, she dominates that stat line. 

Out of these greats, Miller, Catchings Holdsclaw and Stewart helped their programs hoist an NCAA championship trophy. In fact, Stewart led UConn to four consecutive titles and won Most Outstanding Player in each tournament, which hasn't been accomplished by any player in college basketball history. Stewie was the first freshman to win the MOP award since 1987. 

Catchings' 711 points in her first season were the most by a freshman in Lady Vol history. Moore and Smith both helped their programs make a national title appearance in their rookie year. The Buckeyes did not make the NCAA tournament for two years until Smith led the program to title contention. Bueckers and the Huskies were eliminated by Arizona in the Final Four, 69-59. A national title was about the only thing missing from her freshman year.

Here is a look at the Bueckers and the all-time greats' awards and accomplishments during their freshman season: 

HONORS: UConn freshman Paige Bueckers named 2021 Naismith Trophy winner

Paige Bueckers Freshman year honors, courtesy of 

  • 2021 Wooden Award winner
  • 2021 Naismith Trophy winner
  • 2021 AP Player of the Year
  • 2021 USBWA Player and Freshman of the Year
  • 2021 WBCA, AP and USBWA First Team All-American
  • 2021 WBCA Freshman of the Year
  • 2021 Final Four All-Tournament Team
  • 2021 NCAA Tournament River Walk Region Most Outstanding Player
  • 2021 BIG EAST Player and Freshman of the Year
  • 2021 BIG EAST Tournament Most Outstanding Player
  • 2021 All-BIG EAST First Team
  • 2021 BIG EAST All-Freshman Team
  • 2021 espnW Player and Freshman of the Year


Cheryl Miller (1982-83), courtesy of

  • 1983 National Champion
  • 1983 NCAA Tournament MVP 
  • 1983 NCAA All-Tournament selection
  • 1983 Kodak All-American
  • 1983 ABA-USA All-American
  • 1983 Naismith All-American
  • 1983 Fast Break All-American
  • 1983 All-WCAA first team selection


Katie Smith (1992-93) 

  • A part of program's first Final Four appearance 
  • 1993 First-team All-American
  • 1993 Big Ten Freshman of the Year 
  • 1993 Kodak All-American


Chamique Holdsclaw (1995-96)

  • 1996 National Champion 
  • 1996 Kodak All-American
  • 1996 Final Four All-American team 
  • 1996 SEC Championship 


Tamika Catchings (1997-98), courtesy of 

  • 1998 SEC Freshman of the Year
  • 1998 First-Team All-SEC
  • 1998 SEC All-Freshman Team
  • 1998 United States Basketball Writers Association Freshman of the Year
  • 1998 WBCA/Kodak/State Farm All-American
  • 1998 SEC All-Tournament Team


Maya Moore (2007-08), courtesy of 

  • 2008 BIG EAST Player of the Year
  • 2008 Associated Press First Team All-America
  • 2008 State Farm All-America
  • 2008 USBWA All-America
  • 2008 Wooden All-America Team
  • 2008 BIG EAST Freshman of the Year 
  • 2008 USBWA National Freshman of the Year 
  • 2008 All-BIG EAST First Team 
  • 2008 Greensboro Regional Most Outstanding Player 
  • 2008 BIG EAST All-Freshman Team


Breanna Stewart (2012-13), courtesy of 

  • 2013 Final Four MOP
  • 2013 NCAA Tournament Bridgeport Regional MOP
  • 2013 All-BIG EAST Tournament Team
  • 2012-13 BIG EAST All-Freshman Team
  • 2012-13 All-BIG EAST Honorable Mention


Sabrina Ionescu (2016-17), courtesy of 

  • USBWA National Freshman of the Year
  • ESPNW National Freshman of the Year
  • Pac-12 Freshman of the Year
  • All-Pac-12
  • Pac-12 All-Freshman
  • Pac-12 All-Tournament Team
  • NCAA All-Bridgeport Regional Team


The ceiling is high for Bueckers as she prepares for her second year with the Huskies. After helping UConn finish the 2020-21 season as the No. 1 team in the AP's poll — including five consecutive weeks — the Huskies return the same starting lineup, while adding No. 1 recruit Azzi Fudd to its roster, according to espnW's Class of 2021 Rankings. 

Women's college basketball rankings: South Carolina, UConn lead preseason AP Top 25 poll

Here's everything you need to know about the preseason women's college basketball poll.

8 men's basketball Final Four dark horses for the 2022 NCAA tournament, according to Andy Katz

March Madness correspondent Andy Katz says these eight teams could make the Final Four next spring.

UConn women's basketball: Players, stats, records, historic moments from Huskies dynasty

Here's everything you need to know about the UConn women's basketball dynasty, including rosters, stats, records, key moments and quotes.

Subscribe To Email Updates

Enter your information to receive emails about offers, promotions from and our partners