The following players were listed on the most first team All-America teams competing against players at that position only. To be selected a player has to be named first team on at least two of the five selected All-American teams. Second and third teams were used to break ties. Ten players were unanimous choices by the five organizations used in the consensus chart — American Football Coaches Association, Associated Press, Football Writers Association of America, The Sporting News and Walter Camp Foundation. Note: Each of the five teams has a different way of listing the returner or all-purpose player. For the purpose of the Consensus All-America team those categories were treated as one position.
WR—Brandin Cooks, Oregon St., 5-10, 186, Jr.
WR—Mike Evans, Texas A&M, 6-5, 225, So.
TE—*Jace Amaro, Texas Tech, 6-5, 260, Jr.
OL—Cyrus Kouandjio, Alabama, 6-6, 310, Jr.
OL—*David Yankey, Stanford, 6-5, 313, Sr.
OL—*Jake Matthews, Texas A&M, 6-5, 305, Sr.
OL—*Cyril Richardson, Baylor, 6-5, 340, Sr.
C—Bryan Stork, Florida St., 6-4, 300, Sr.
C—Gabe Ikard, Oklahoma, 6-3, 298, Sr.
QB—Jameis Winston, Florida St., 6-4, 229, Fr.
RB—*Andre Williams, Boston College, 6-0, 227, Sr.
RB—Ka'Deem Carey, Arizona, 5-10, 207, Jr.
PK—Anthony Fera, Texas, 6-2, 208, Sr.
Returner/All-Purpose—Ty Montgomery, Stanford, 6-2, 215, Jr.
DL—*Aaron Donald, Pittsburgh, 6-0, 285, Sr.
DL—*Michael Sam, Missouri, 6-2, 255, Sr.
DL—Jackson Jeffcoat, Texas, 6-5, 250, Sr.
DL—Vic Beasley, Clemson, 6-2, 235, Jr.
LB—*C.J. Mosley, Alabama, 6-2, 238, Sr.
LB—Anthony Barr, UCLA, 6-4, 248, Sr.
LB—Trent Murphy, Stanford, 6-6, 261, Sr.
DB—*Darqueze Dennard, Michigan St., 5-11, 197, Sr.
DB—*Lamarcus Joyner, Florida St., 5-8, 190, Sr.
DB—Ha Ha Clinton-Dix, Alabama, 6-1, 208, Jr.
DB—Justin Gilbert, Oklahoma St., 6-0, 200, Sr.
P—Tom Hornsey, Memphis, 6-3, 210, Sr.
* Indicates unanimous first team selection; Bold indicates consensus repeater from 2012
Note: Two centers are named because of a tie. Both Stork and Ikard made two first teams and one second team each.