football-fbs flag

Jacob Myers | | January 16, 2019

How new Oklahoma quarterback Jalen Hurts' numbers compare to Heisman winners Baker Mayfield, Kyler Murray

Oklahoma's Kyler Murray is the 2018 Heisman Trophy winner

Oklahoma just won a commitment from undoubtedly the biggest name on the college football transfer market in former Alabama quarterback Jalen Hurts.

While Kyler Murray mulls over his options of whether or not to go to the NFL or pursue a career in MLB, Lincoln Riley was still going to need to find a quarterback to — once again — replace a Heisman Trophy winner.

On the face, the three seasons Hurts spent in the Alabama offense doesn't necessarily translate to the offense he is expected to run at Oklahoma as a graduate transfer in 2019. However, we can still measure a few stats of his to Mayfield and Murray to project whether or not Oklahoma will make the College Football Playoff in the 2019 college football season. Stats from Hurts' 2018 season isn't included because he wasn't the starting quarterback.

MORE: Jalen Hurts transfers to Oklahoma

Let’s just get the obvious out of the way: Hurts doesn’t come close to Mayfield and Murray in total passing yards. In Hurts’ two full seasons as the starter for the Crimson Tide, he threw for a combined 4,681 yards, 40 touchdowns and 10 interceptions. In 2017, when Mayfield won the Heisman Trophy, the gunslinger threw for 4,627 yards, 43 touchdown passes and six interceptions. This past season, Murray threw for 4,361 yards, 42 touchdown passes and seven picks.

It’s impossible to have an precise comparison of these players in passing stats, but Hurts is still a pretty accurate passer. This season, in limited time, he completed 70 percent of his passes for 10.9 yards per attempt.

Year Player Completions Attempts Completion % Yards per Attempt Touchdowns Interceptions Pass Efficiency Rating
2016 Jalen Hurts (FR) 240 382 62.8 7.3 23 9 139.1
  Baker Mayfield (JR) 254 358 70.9 11.1 40 8 196.4
2017 Jalen Hurts (SO) 154 255 60.4 8.2 17 1 150.2
  Baker Mayfield (SR) 285 404 70.5 11.5 43 6 198.9
2018 Kyler Murray (JR) 260 377 69.0 11.6 42 7 199.2

There’s little doubt Hurts’ numbers will rise in 2019 with the Sooners offense because of the type of system Riley runs, but by how much? At Alabama, Hurts had six games throwing more than 30 times in his first year with the Tide, but had zero in 2017. Mayfield had seven in each season. Expect Hurts to throw the ball much more if Oklahoma is to make the playoff for a third straight season.

MORE: 15 games that could affect the College Football Playoff in 2019

Hurts is more of a runner than Mayfield, so he might use his feet in a similar way Murray did this most recent college football season. Hurts had 10 or more carries in 10 games in 2017 while Murray had eight such games in 2018. Murray — and Mayfield for that matter — was more involved in the overall offensive output the past two years than Hurts was in 2016 and 2017. But here’s a look at the average yards per play each player had in those respective seasons.

    Rushing attempts Passing attempts Rushing yards Passing yards Yards per total attempts Touchdowns
2016 Jalen Hurts (FR) 191 382 954 2780 6.52 36
2017 Jalen Hurts (SO) 154 255 855 2081 7.18 25
2018 Kyler Murray (JR) 140 377 1001 4361 10.37 54

Clearly, Murray has been the more productive player, which is what you would expect from the player that just broke the passer efficiency rating that his teammate (Mayfield) broke the year before.

Hurts hasn’t been a legitimate Heisman candidate so these numbers are by no means standards that his 2019 season should be compared to. And it’s worth considering the defenses Oklahoma quarterbacks and Hurts have played against in their careers. Here are the ranks of the defenses that Hurts played against in 2016 and 2017 compared to Mayfield.

    Games Best defense Worst defense Avg. defense
2016 Jalen Hurts (FR) 15 5th 100th 47.1
  Baker Mayfield (JR) 13 3rd 128th 63.9
2017 Jalen Hurts (SO) 14 2nd 115th 46.8
  Baker Mayfield (SR) 14 6th 129th 63

The Oklahoma Sooners certainly got a quarterback that has proven he’s good enough to lead a team to the College Football Playoff and has experienced in the most important game — the national championship. But how he translates into the pass-happy Oklahoma offense remains to be seen.

2023 Alabama football schedule: Dates, times, TV channels, scores

Check out the 2023 Alabama Crimson Tide's football schedule. This will be updated all season long for game times, TV channels and scores.

College Football Playoff rankings predictions: What conference championship week could look like

The fifth College Football Playoff rankings will be revealed on Tuesday, Nov. 28. Here's what the top 25 could look like.

2023 SEC Championship Game: Date, time, history

Here's the quick guide to the 2023 SEC Championship Game, which will have the SEC East and SEC West champions face off.

Subscribe To Email Updates

Enter your information to receive emails about offers, promotions from and our partners