| SPORT | DIVISION | SCHOOL | TITLES | YEARS |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baseball | DI | USC | 5 | 1970-74 |
| DII | Tampa | 2 | 2006-07 | |
| Tampa | 2 | 1992-93 | ||
| Jacksonville State | 2 | 1990-91 | ||
| Troy | 2 | 1986-87 | ||
| UC Irvine | 2 | 1973-74 | ||
| Florida Southern | 2 | 1971-72 | ||
| DIII | Marietta | 2 | 2011-12 | |
| Rowan | 2 | 1978-79 | ||
| Cal State-Stanislaus | 2 | 1976-77 | ||
| (M) Basketball | DI | UCLA | 7 | 1967-73 |
| DII | Cal State Bakersfield | 2 | 1993-94 | |
| Kentucky Wesleyan | 2 | 1968-69 | ||
| Evansville | 2 | 1964-65 | ||
| Evansville | 2 | 1959-60 | ||
| DIII | North Park | 3 | 1978-80 | |
| (W) Basketball | DI | Connecticut | 4 | 2013-16 |
| DII | North Dakota State | 4 | 1993-96 | |
| DIII | Washington-St. Louis | 4 | 1998-2001 | |
| Bowling | NC | Maryland-Eastern Shore | 2 | 2011-12 |
| Nebraska | 2 | 2004-05 | ||
| (M) Cross Country | DI | Arkansas | 4 | 1990-93 |
| UTEP | 4 | 1978-81 | ||
| DII | Western State | 4 | 1999-2002 | |
| DIII | North Central (Ill.) | 3 | 1997-99 | |
| Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 3 | 1988-90 | ||
| (W) Cross Country | DI | Villanova | 6 | 1989-94 |
| DII | Cal Poly | 10 | 1982-91 | |
| DIII | SUNY Cortland | 4 | 1992-95 | |
| Fencing | NC | Penn State | 6 | 1994-2000 |
| Field Hockey | DI | Wake Forest | 3 | 2002-04 |
| North Carolina | 3 | 1995-97 | ||
| Old Dominion | 3 | 1990-92 | ||
| Old Dominion | 3 | 1982-84 | ||
| DII | Bloomsburg | 4 | 2006-09 | |
| Bloomsburg | 4 | 1996-99 | ||
| DIII | Salisbury | 3 | 2003-05 | |
| Football | FBS * | Alabama | 2 | 2011-12 |
| USC | 2 | 2003-04 | ||
| Nebraska | 2 | 1994-95 | ||
| Alabama | 2 | 1978-79 | ||
| Oklahoma | 2 | 1974-75 | ||
| Nebraska | 2 | 1970-71 | ||
| Alabama | 2 | 1964-65 | ||
| Oklahoma | 2 | 1955-56 | ||
| Notre Dame | 2 | 1946-47 | ||
| Army | 2 | 1944-45 | ||
| Minnesota | 2 | 1940-41 | ||
| FCS | Appalachian State | 3 | 2005-07 | |
| DII | North Alabama | 3 | 1993-95 | |
| DIII | Augustana (Ill.) | 4 | 1983-86 | |
| (M) Golf | DI | Yale | 8 | 1905-12 |
| DII | South Carolina-Aiken | 3 | 2004-06 | |
| Florida Southern | 3 | 1998-2000 | ||
| DIII | Methodist | 6 | 1994-99 | |
| Cal State-Stanislaus | 6 | 1984-89 | ||
| Cal State-Stanislaus | 6 | 1976-81 | ||
| (W) Golf | DI | Duke | 3 | 2005-07 |
| Arizona State | 3 | 1993-95 | ||
| DII | Nova Southeastern | 4 | 2009-12 | |
| Rollins | 4 | 2003-06 | ||
| DIII | Methodist | 13 | 2000-12 | |
| (M) Gymnastics | NC | Nebraska | 5 | 1979-83 |
| (W) Gymnastics | NC | Georgia | 5 | 2005-09 |
| Utah | 5 | 1982-86 | ||
| (M) Ice Hockey | DI | Michigan | 3 | 1951-53 |
| DIII | Middlebury | 5 | 1995-99 | |
| (W) Ice Hockey | NC | Minnesota-Duluth | 3 | 2001-2003 |
| DIII | Middlebury | 3 | 2004-06 | |
| (M) Lacrosse | DI | Princeton | 3 | 1996-98 |
| Johns Hopkins | 3 | 1978-80 | ||
| DII | C.W. Post | 2 | 2009-10 | |
| Le Moyne | 2 | 2006-07 | ||
| Adelphi | 2 | 1998-99 | ||
| Adelphi | 2 | 1981 / 1993 ** | ||
| Hobart | 2 | 1976-77 | ||
| DIII | Hobart | 12 | 1980-91 | |
| (W) Lacrosse | DI | Maryland | 7 | 1995-2001 |
| DII | Adelphi | 3 | 2009-11 | |
| DIII | TCNJ | 6 | 1991-96 | |
| Rifle | NC | Alaska-Fairbanks | 6 | 1999-2004 |
| West Virginia | 6 | 1988-93 | ||
| Rowing | DI | Brown | 2 | 2007-08 |
| California | 2 | 2005-06 | ||
| Brown | 2 | 1999-2000 | ||
| Washington | 2 | 1997-98 | ||
| DII | Western Washington | 7 | 2005-11 | |
| DIII | Williams | 8 | 2006-13 | |
| Skiing | NC | Colorado # | 8 | 1972-79 |
| (M) Soccer | DI | Virginia | 4 | 1991-94 |
| DII | Southern Connecticut State | 2 | 1998-99 | |
| Seattle Pacific | 2 | 1985-86 | ||
| DIII | Messiah | 3 | 2008-10 | |
| Messiah | 3 | 2004-06 | ||
| UNC-Greensboro | 3 | 1985-87 | ||
| (W) Soccer | DI | North Carolina | 9 | 1986-94 |
| DII | Franklin Pierce | 4 | 1994-97 | |
| DIII | UC San Diego | 3 | 1995-97 | |
| Softball | DI | UCLA | 3 | 1988-90 |
| DII | Cal State-Bakersfield | 3 | 1988-90 | |
| Cal State-Northridge | 3 | 1983-85 | ||
| DIII | St. Thomas (Minn.) | 2 | 2004-05 | |
| Eastern Connecticut State | 2 | 1985-86 | ||
| (M) Swimming & Diving | DI | Indiana | 6 | 1968-73 |
| DII | Drury | 8 | 2005-2012 | |
| Cal State-Bakersfield | 8 | 1986-93 | ||
| DIII | Kenyon | 31 | 1980-2010 | |
| (W) Swimming & Diving | DI | Stanford | 5 | 1992-96 |
| Texas | 5 | 1984-88 | ||
| DII | Truman | 6 | 2001-06 | |
| DIII | Kenyon | 17 | 1984-2000 | |
| (M) Tennis | DI | USC | 4 | 2009-12 |
| Stanford | 4 | 1995-98 | ||
| USC | 4 | 1966-69 | ||
| DII | Lander | 8 | 1993-2000 | |
| DIII | Kalamazoo | 3 | 1991-93 | |
| (W) Tennis | DI | Stanford | 6 | 1986-91 |
| DII | SIU-Edwardsville | 4 | 1986-89 | |
| DIII | Williams | 6 | 2008-13 | |
| (M) Indoor Track & Field | DI | Arkansas | 12 | 1984-95 |
| DII | St. Augustine's ## | 6 | 1987-92 | |
| DIII | Wisconsin-La Crosse | 6 | 2001-06 | |
| (W) Indoor Track & Field | DI | LSU | 5 | 1993-97 |
| DII | Abilene Christian | 8 | 1993-2000 | |
| DIII | Wheaton (Mass.) | 5 | 1999-2003 | |
| (M) Outdoor Track & Field | DI | USC | 9 | 1935-43 |
| DII | Abilene Christian | 7 | 2002-08 | |
| St. Augustine's | 7 | 1989-95 | ||
| Abilene Christian | 7 | 1982-88 | ||
| DIII | Rowan | 5 | 1980-84 | |
| (W) Outdoor Track & Field | DI | LSU | 11 | 1987-97 |
| DII | Lincoln (Mo.) | 5 | 2003-07 | |
| DIII | Wheaton (Mass.) | 3 | 2001-03 | |
| Wisconsin-Oshkosh | 3 | 1995-97 | ||
| Christopher Newport | 3 | 1987-89 | ||
| (M) Volleyball | NC | UCLA | 4 | 1981-84 |
| DIII | Springfield | 2 | 2012-13 | |
| (W) Volleyball | DI | Penn State | 4 | 2007-10 |
| DII | Concordia-St. Paul | 7 | 2007-2013 | |
| DIII | Washington-St. Louis | 6 | 1991-96 | |
| (M) Water Polo | NC | USC | 6 | 2008-13 |
| (W) Water Polo | NC | UCLA | 5 | 2005-09 |
| Wrestling | DI | Iowa | 9 | 1978-86 |
| DII | Cal Poly | 7 | 1968-74 | |
| DIII | Wartburg | 3 | 2011-13 | |
| Augsburg | 3 | 2000-2002 | ||
| * AP since 1936 | ** No DII tournament 1982-92 | # Shared title with Dartmouth (1976) | ## Shared title with Abilene Christian (1988) | ||||