wrestling-d1 flag

Shannon Scovel | NCAA.com | December 15, 2019

Oklahoma State vs. Oklahoma wrestling: Cowboys prevail 23-9 in the Bedlam rivalry dual

Oklahoma State's Daton Fix reads heartfelt letter from his parents

For the first time in three years, Oklahoma hosted in-state rival Oklahoma State in Norman for the annual Bedlam rivalry dual, inspiring a barn-burner of a wrestling match. These two teams have combined for 41 NCAA titles and brought a total of 10 ranked wrestlers to the mat Sunday afternoon between them for their 179th meeting in history. Oklahoma State picked up the dominant win 23-9 and now holds the advantage 142-27-10 across the previous duals. The Cowboys have won all of the meetings since 2013, and Sunday's win continued this trend. 

Each team had taken a loss already this season heading into the dual, but, after losing seven of the ten weight classes, the Sooners were the team to pick up the second L. Here are the three things we learned from the dual as well as an overview of each weight class. 

1. No Gfeller, no Smith, no problem 

The Cowboys didn't need two of their strong assets on Sunday, as head coach John Smith held both Kaden Gfeller and Joe Smith out of the lineup again. Dusty Hone came in for Gfeller at 141 pounds and pushed a competitive Dom Demas before dropping a tight 6-4 decision for Oklahoma's first win of the night. Andrew Shomers stepped in for Smith, and suffered an overtime loss to Anthony Mantnona in a high-scoring 10-8 bout. The timeline for the return of these two athletes is still unclear, but Oklahoma State proved that it can keep its Bedlam success rolling with the depth in its lineup. 

ON THE PODIUM: Bedlam featured three All-Americans from the 2019 season 

One of the biggest powerhouse wrestlers in the Cowboys lineup, Nick Piccininni, continued his dominance with a 14-2 major decision over Christian Moody. The Cowboy senior finished fifth at NCAAs last year to earn his second All-American honor and looks to be on track in his quest for a third trophy. Piccininni is now 6-0 against Moody and undefeated in Bedlam. 

Freshman Reece Witcraft also impressed, stopping Anthony Madrigal for his first Bedlam win against a ranked opponent. 

165-pounder No. 14 Travis Wittlake and 149-pounder No. 4 Boo Lewallen also both picked up wins in the dual, stayed undefeated and doing what they needed to do to put themselves in the best position to hold their top 25 spots in the rankings. Wittlake took on Sam Dover and earned a solid 3-2 decision. Lewallen wrestled Jacob Butler for a 12-4 major decision win. The bonus points weren't necessary from Lewallen for the team score, but they are sure nice for the All-American to add to his stats this year. 

2. The Sooners have some scorers, just not enough

After losing last year's Bedlam dual by the largest margin than they have since 1992, the Sooners welcomed Oklahoma State to Norman ready to keep the score close. Both Demas and Thomas racked up points today, as did Anthony Mantnona, giving Oklahoma more than three times as many team points as last year. Demas' win also keeps him undefeated in his Bedlam career. 

3. Dakota Geer is as good as we expected

Of all 10 matchups set for Sunday afternoon, only one contained two top-10 ranked wrestlers: 197 pounds. Oklahoma State All-American Dakota Geer took on Oklahoma's Jacob Woodley and put up a solid 4-2 decision win over the U23 World Team Trials Champion. Geer had the statistical advantage based on season winning percentage, NCAA tournament finishes and bonus rate advantage heading into the dual, and he backed all of that up with a victory.  

WHAT HAPPENED IN VEGAS: Here's what you need to know about the 2019 Cliff Keen Invitational results

Full results from the dual: 

125 pounds - No. 4 Nick Piccininni vs. Christian Moody: This match was all Picc. The two-time All-American shot out to an early lead off a quick first-period takedown and worked his opponent the entire seven minutes. He picked up points in the first period and continued running up the scoreboard before ending up with a 14-2 major decision. That's how you rebound from a loss against Princeton. 

133 pounds- Reece Witcraft vs. No. 18 Anthony Madrigal: Welcome to the Witcraft Show! The Oklahoma State freshman has been unstoppable in his recent duals, scrambling hard and taking down big-time opponents. The 6-5 win against Madrigal gave Oklahoma State three more team points and expanded their lead to 7-0 after two bouts. 

141 pounds -  Dusty Hone vs. No. 4 Dom Demas: Dusty Hone fought tough, but he didn't have quite enough to stop Demas, a 2019 Big 12 champion and All-American. The Sooner sophomore picked up a quick takedown in the first and followed that with a counterattack before the end up the second period. Demas held strong and finished with a 6-4 win to give Oklahoma its first team points of the day. 

149 pounds - No. 4 Boo Lewallen vs. Jacob Butler: A takedown and a two-point turn gave NCAA All-American Boo Lewallen a 4-0 lead against Butler at the start of the first period and racked up riding time before giving up his first takedown at the start of the second period. The third period, though, was all Boo. Two more takedowns put him up 11-4, and riding put him over the bonus point edge to give the Cowboys an 11-3 lead after four bouts. 

157 pounds- Wyatt Sheets vs. No. 17 Justin Thomas: The ranked wrestler picked up the win in this one, but only after a seven-minute battle. Two takedowns for Thomas put him up 4-2 to start the third, and that's when his toughness kicked in. The Sooner held strong to finish with a 5-3 decision and add three more points to the Sooner total. 

LEGENDS: These are our 10 all-time dream college wrestling matchups at every weight 

165 pounds - No. 14 Travis Wittlake vs. Sam Dover: In a match that seemed destined for overtime, Oklahoma State's Travis Wittlake pulled out a gritty third-period rideout to notch the final point needed to give him the 3-2 decision against Dover. Wittlake avoided the upset and put the Cowboys ahead 13-6 at this point in the dual. 

174 pounds-  Andrew Shomers vs. Anthony Mantnona: Now this one really did go to overtime, and it was Anthony Mantnona who found his position and scored the winning takedown against Oklahoma State's Andrew Shomers for the 10-8 decision. The win closed Oklahoma State's gap to just four points, setting up the Sooners for a potential comeback. 

184 pounds - Anthony Montalvo vs. Darrien Roberts: So much for the Sooner comeback. Anthony Montalvo earned a quick six points after a takedown and back points to give himself a strong lead after the first couple minutes. Another takedown extended his first period lead to 8-1, and the match was all his. Roberts did put up two more takedowns of his own, but he couldn't close the gap and Montalvo took the W 13-5. 

197 pounds- Dakota Geer vs. Jake Woodley: Geer picked up the first points, but Woodley's two escapes made the score 4-2 after the second period. The big guys ended the match with zero points in the third to give Geer the 4-2 decision and seal the deal for the Cowboys. 

285 pounds- Austin Harris vs. Josiah Jones: Austin Harris put an exclamation mark on the dual for Oklahoma State with a workmanlike 6-2 decision to earn his second dual win. The Cowboys owned this match from start to finish, with the exception of 141, 157 and 174 pounds. 

5 storylines to follow this college wrestling season

Penn State will once again be a hot topic leading into the 2023-2024 college wrestling season, so here's everything you need to know about the Blue and White, as well as the teams, coaches and athletes that will be looking to challenge the reigning champs this year. 

D1Softball's top 100 college softball players from 2023

Who were the best players of the 2023 college softball season? Based on offensive stats, defensive impact, value to their team, advanced metrics and a splash of postseason success, D1Softball compiled the best 100 players of this past season.

5 major men's college wrestling transfer portal moves — and how they impact the 2024 team title race

Here’s a look at the biggest transfer headlines in college wrestling this summer and how these moves might impact the 2024 NCAA wrestling team race.